Research
The Retracted Apple Cider Vinegar Study and Slim Melt
The retracted apple cider vinegar weight study is the March 2024 trial in Lebanese teens and young adults. BMJ withdrew it in September 2025 because of unreliable data, implausible statistics and no advance trial registration. A 2025 meta-analysis still counted it, so its large weight numbers are best left out when you read about SlimMelt.
Written by the Slim Melt editorial teamUpdated · 8 min read

In brief
Why was the apple cider vinegar weight loss study retracted?
Because the journal could no longer trust its data or its statistics. BMJ Group retracted the trial on September 25, 2025, and said its results are unreliable (BMJ Group, 2025).
The trial had appeared in March 2024 in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health. It drew wide news coverage. Eighteen months later it was gone from the scientific record.
Apple cider vinegar is Slim Melt's headline ingredient, and the retracted numbers still circulate in ads. Readers deserve to know which studies stand.
The claim
What did the retracted ACV study say it tested?
It described a 12-week randomized trial of 120 adolescents and young adults in Lebanon with overweight or obesity (NutraIngredients, 2025). Groups were said to take 5, 10 or 15 mL of apple cider vinegar at 5% acetic acid, stirred into 250 mL of water each day, or a placebo.
The paper reported large drops in weight and other measures. We are not repeating those figures. BMJ asked journalists and others to stop referencing or using the results (BMJ Group, 2025), and we agree.
Slim Melt pages never cite the retracted trial's results as evidence. We describe it only to explain the retraction.
The problems
What problems did reviewers find in the vinegar trial?
Five concerns, all listed in BMJ Group's retraction notice and in reporting on it.
| Concern | What it means in plain words |
|---|---|
| Statistical analysis | The methods used to compare groups were not sound, and outside statisticians could not reproduce the results. |
| Implausible values | Some numbers were too neat to be likely. Reviewers noted improbably small P-values. |
| Raw data reliability | The journal could not be confident the underlying data were accurate. |
| Methods reporting | The paper did not explain clearly enough how the trial was run. |
| No prospective registration | The trial was not registered before it began, so its plan could not be checked against its results. |
Reviewers also found patterns that did not fit random assignment to groups (NutraIngredients, 2025). Random assignment is what makes a trial fair.
Timeline
How did the ACV study go from headline to retraction?
- March 2024
The trial is published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health (BMJ Group, 2025).
- March 12, 2024
Experts react through the Science Media Centre. A professor at the University of Navarra faults the use of simple t-tests instead of repeated-measures models and the lack of data on what participants ate, and urges considerable caution (Science Media Centre, 2024).
- 2025
A meta-analysis of vinegar trials appears in Nutrients, with the Lebanese trial among its included studies (Nutrients, 2025).
- September 25, 2025
BMJ Group retracts the trial (BMJ Group, 2025).
- October 1, 2025
Trade press reports that the authors called the errors honest mistakes but agreed with the retraction. The journal's editor says publishing without trial registration was, in hindsight, the wrong decision (NutraIngredients, 2025).
The meta-analysis
Why did a 2025 meta-analysis still include the retracted trial?
The review pooled 10 randomized trials, and the Lebanese trial is on its list of included studies. The paper does not mention the retraction (Nutrients, 2025).
Timing is the most likely reason. Both events landed in 2025, and a review is written, checked and peer reviewed over many months, so a trial pulled late in the year can already be part of a review's numbers. Whatever the cause, the effect is the same: one unreliable trial sits inside the pooled result.
The authors themselves flagged other limits. Trials were short, 4 to 12 weeks. Five had a high risk of bias. Results varied a lot between studies, with heterogeneity of 61% to 83%, and publication bias was possible (Nutrients, 2025). With the retracted trial inside, the pooled result is likely inflated.
When an ad cites "a 2025 meta-analysis" for vinegar and weight, remember that it counted a retracted trial and that its own authors called the evidence limited.

Try Slim Melt, 2 gummies a day1000 mg ACV · 3 B vitamins · free standard shipping on the listing
Order nowWhat is left
What apple cider vinegar research still stands?
Watch how far each option climbs. Higher means stronger kinds of evidence.
- 4Reviews of good trials
- 3Several trials
- 2Small human trials
- 1Lab and animal studies
- Liquid vinegar for weightSmall trials; modest loss(Biosci Biotechnol Biochem, 2009) (J Funct Foods, 2018) (Nutrients, 2025)
- ACV gummies for weightNo trials found(ConsumerLab, 2020)
- B vitamins for energyOnly helps if deficient(Harvard Health, 2025)
- Diet plus activityWell established(CDC, Losing Weight) (CDC, Physical Activity)
Higher means stronger kinds of evidence. A 2025 meta-analysis of vinegar trials still counted a trial that was retracted the same year, so its pooled result is likely too rosy.
| Trial | Who and how long | Daily vinegar | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Japan, 2009 | Adults with obesity, 12 weeks | 15 or 30 mL in a drink | Stands; modest changes vs placebo |
| Iran, 2018 | 39 dieting adults, 12 weeks | 30 mL plus a calorie-cut diet | Stands; small and short |
| Lebanon, 2024 | 120 teens and young adults, 12 weeks | 5, 10 or 15 mL in water | Retracted in 2025; do not use |
The remaining trials are small and short, and they tested liquid vinegar. Harvard Health calls the case for vinegar as a reliable, long-term weight tool not compelling (Harvard Health, 2023). Mayo Clinic says research has not proved it helps people slim down (Mayo Clinic, 2025).
For Slim Melt buyers
Does the retraction change anything about Slim Melt?
It changes the context, not the product. Slim Melt was never tested in that trial or any other. Two gummies carry 1000 mg of vinegar powder at 5% or more total acids, at least about 50 mg of acids, while even the smallest retracted-trial dose of 5 mL of liquid would hold more than that.
The fair way to judge any vinegar product is against the trials that still stand, and those used 15 to 30 mL of liquid a day. See the math in ACV gummies vs liquid vinegar and the brand's claims checked one by one on the claims and evidence page.

Check for yourself
How can you check if a study has been retracted?
Open the original article
Journals mark retracted papers with a banner or a "Retracted" label on the article page.
Search the title plus "retraction"
Press releases and news reports usually follow, as they did here (BMJ Group, 2025) (NutraIngredients, 2025).
Check the date of any review
A review that appeared around the time of a retraction may still include the pulled study, as the 2025 vinegar review did (Nutrients, 2025).
Health claims for supplements are supposed to rest on competent and reliable scientific evidence, generally human trials (FTC, 2022). A retracted trial is not that. More reading on judging claims is in our post on how much acetic acid is in ACV gummies.
Bottom line
What is the takeaway from the retracted ACV study?
The biggest apple cider vinegar weight result of recent years was withdrawn, and a review built partly on it now overstates the case. What remains is a handful of small liquid-vinegar trials with modest results. Treat any vinegar product, gummies included, as a minor extra to eating and activity habits.
FAQ
Retracted ACV study FAQ
Which apple cider vinegar weight study was retracted, and when?
Yes. BMJ Group retracted the 2024 trial in Lebanese adolescents and young adults on September 25, 2025, over concerns about its statistics, raw data, methods reporting and lack of advance registration. BMJ said its results are unreliable and should no longer be used.
Who published the retracted apple cider vinegar study?
It appeared in March 2024 in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention and Health, a BMJ Group journal. The same publisher later retracted it. Trade press reported that the authors called the errors honest mistakes but agreed with the retraction.
Is there any real evidence that apple cider vinegar helps weight loss?
Some, but it is weak. Small trials of 15 to 30 mL of liquid vinegar a day found modest changes over 12 weeks. Mayo Clinic says research has not proved vinegar helps people slim down, and no trial has tested ACV gummies.
Does the 2025 apple cider vinegar meta-analysis still count?
Read it with care. It pooled 10 trials, including the one retracted in 2025, without noting the retraction. Its authors also reported short trials, high risk of bias in five studies and large differences between studies, so its pooled result is likely too optimistic.
Why do some ads still quote the retracted ACV trial?
Retracted results keep circulating because old articles and ads are rarely updated. If a vinegar product cites big weight losses from a 2024 trial, check whether it is the retracted one. BMJ asked that its results not be referenced.
Did Slim Melt rely on the retracted vinegar study?
No trial of Slim Melt exists, retracted or otherwise. Our pages describe the retracted study only to explain why its numbers should not be used. The gummies' acid dose is also far below the liquid doses used in vinegar trials.
Why did BMJ retract the apple cider vinegar trial behind Slim Melt style claims?
BMJ retracted the trial in September 2025 over unreliable data, implausible statistics and no advance trial registration. Because of this, its reported weight losses should not be used as evidence for any apple cider vinegar product, including Slim Melt.
Should I trust Slim Melt or other ACV gummy ads that quote the retracted study?
No. Any ad quoting that retracted trial rests on data BMJ withdrew. Check whether a claim cites a retracted study before you trust it. Slim Melt is best judged on its label facts, such as 1000 mg ACV per serving.
What was wrong with the retracted ACV trial?
BMJ pulled it in September 2025 for unreliable data, implausible statistics and no advance trial registration.
Who wrote this
Written and reviewed by
Plain-language pages built from the label, the sales listing and linked public health sources.
Last updated . Read our editorial standards and how we check reviews. This website is run by Theslimmelt, a U.S. stocking partner, not by the manufacturer. We earn money when you buy through our order links.
Keep reading
More about Slim Melt

Claims and evidence
Every benefit on the brand graphics, checked against published research and the printed label.
Read more
Gummies vs liquid
A tablespoon of vinegar against two gummies: the acid math, the trade-offs and who each form suits.
Read more
Acetic acid in ACV gummies
Milligrams of vinegar times percent acids: how to read any ACV gummy label, with Slim Melt as the example.
Read moreU.S. stocking partner for Slim Melt
Ready to try Slim Melt?
Pick a quantity. Two gummies a day, 30 days per bottle. Read the listing's return line before you buy.
- Checkout on eBay
- Free standard shipping (listing)
- eBay protection for problem orders
